Free Shipping on All Bundles
CBT for Overthinkers: The Power of Reframing

CBT for Overthinkers: The Power of Reframing

by Ethan Amero in Resources

It's 8pm. You're supposed to be watching a show, but you're replaying that 2pm meeting in your head for the fifteenth time. Your manager said "interesting approach" when you presented your idea. But the way she said it felt... off. Was it actually interesting? Or was that code for "this won't work"? 

Welcome to the overthinker's evening routine. Population: most of us.

Your Brain Is Trying to Protect You

Here's what's happening. Your brain evolved to scan for threats. In prehistoric times, misreading social cues could get you kicked out of the tribe, which basically meant death. So your brain got really, really good at analyzing every interaction for hidden danger. 

The problem? Your brain can't tell the difference between actual threats and "my boss sounded weird in a meeting." It treats both with the same level of alarm.

Dr. Dan Siegel, a clinical professor of psychiatry at UCLA, describes this beautifully with the phrase "name it to tame it." When you can specifically identify what you're feeling and thinking, you take away its power to hijack your evening.

But naming it is just the first step.

The Story Your Brain Is Telling

Here's what CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) researchers discovered. We don't react to events themselves. We react to the story we tell ourselves about those events.

That meeting didn't ruin your evening. Your interpretation of that meeting did.

The good news? If your brain can create one story, it can create others. And some of those other stories might be closer to the truth.

Try This Right Now

Think about a work interaction you've been replaying. Got one? Good.

Now write down the story you've been telling yourself. Be honest. Mine might be:

My Story: "She thinks my idea is stupid and she's too polite to say it directly. I'm probably going to get sidelined on this project."

Now here's the practice. Generate three alternative interpretations of the same event. Not optimistic fairy tales, just other plausible explanations.

  1. "She genuinely found it interesting but needs time to think through the implications before committing."

  2. "She was distracted by the budget meeting right after ours and didn't fully process what I said."

  3. "She uses 'interesting' as a neutral placeholder word, and I'm reading tone that wasn't there."

Notice what just happened? You went from one catastrophic interpretation to four possible explanations. Suddenly your brain has less to grip onto and reality feels a lot more manageable. 

An All Too Common Example

Let me show you how this works with another scenario.

The Event: Your colleague didn't respond to your Slack message for three hours, but you saw them active in other channels.

Your First Story: "They're avoiding me. I must have annoyed them in yesterday's meeting. They're probably complaining about me to other people right now."

Alternative Interpretations:

  1. "They saw my message while dealing with something urgent and genuinely forgot to respond."

  2. "They need to check with someone else before answering and haven't had a chance yet."

  3. "They're active in channels where they're tagged because notifications demand immediate attention, but they're batching responses to everything else."

Which interpretation is true? You probably won't know until tomorrow. But that's the point. Your brain was treating the first story as fact when it was just one possible explanation among many.

Why This Works

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy has been studied extensively for decades. Research from Dr. Aaron Beck (the founder of CBT) and thousands of other studies show that changing thought patterns literally changes brain activity.

When you actively generate alternative interpretations, you're not being naive or practicing toxic positivity. You're training your brain to recognize its own habit of jumping to worst-case conclusions.

Most overthinkers aren't bad at reading situations. They're just really good at finding the most anxiety-inducing interpretation and treating it as gospel.

The Evening Application

This reframing technique is most powerful when you use it as part of a shutdown practice. Before you transition from work to personal time, catch those thoughts that are still spinning.

Write them down. Then ask yourself: what are three other ways this could be true?

You might use a journal with guided prompts (this is a core part of OFF). You might have a notes document. You might talk it through with someone. 

What matters is that you interrupt the pattern of letting one interpretation dominate your entire evening.

See what happens to the grip it has on you.

The work will be there tomorrow. Tonight belongs to you.

Previous Post Next Post

Related Posts

From Guilt to Growth: Redefining What "Productive Evenings" Mean

From Guilt to Growth: Redefining What "Productive Evenings" Mean

Here's a question: 8 productive hours vs 12 burnt-out hours. Which one wins in the long term?  The Hustle Culture Trap Somewhere along the way, the hustle bros sold us a lie. That every hour should be optimized. That downtime is wasted time. That "productive evening" means squeezing in more work, more learning, more doing. Instagram tells us successful people wake up at 4am, rub a banana peel on their face, dunk their head in ice-cold sparkling water, and have three side hustles. LinkedIn celebrates people who "grind" 80-hour weeks. TikTok productivity gurus sell us on the idea that if we're not constantly improving, we're falling behind. The result? We've turned our evenings into overtime. Not official overtime that shows up on a timesheet, but the kind where we judge ourselves for not doing more. You worked a full day. Then you feel guilty for not working a second shift on yourself. What Actually Happens When You Rest Dr. Alex Soojung-Kim Pang spent years researching high performers for his book "Rest: Why You Get More Done When You Work Less." His findings challenge everything hustle culture preaches. The most productive people aren't the ones who work the longest hours. They're the ones who rest deliberately. Here's why. Your brain doesn't stop working when you stop doing. When you're genuinely relaxed, your mind enters what neuroscientists call "default mode network." This is when your brain consolidates memories, makes unexpected connections, and does the deep processing that fuels creativity and problem-solving. But this only happens when you're actually resting. Not when you're scrolling your phone feeling guilty. Not when you're watching a show while mentally reviewing tomorrow's to-do list. Real rest requires presence. The Real ROI of Rest Let's talk return on investment, since that's the language hustle culture speaks. A study published in the Journal of Applied Psychology found that employees who psychologically detached from work during non-work time showed better performance, higher engagement, and greater life satisfaction. The ones who stayed mentally tethered? Lower performance across the board. Here's the math: spending your evening in work mode means you show up tomorrow already tired. You put in hours, but they're low-quality hours. You're running on fumes, making more mistakes, taking longer on tasks. Spending your evening truly present means you show up tomorrow actually rested. Clearer thinking. Better decisions. More creative solutions. You work fewer hours but they're high-impact hours. So which is more productive? Grinding through 12 burnt-out hours or working 8 sharp ones? The second option also happens to include time for the people and activities that make life worth living. Turns out you don't have to choose between success and sanity. Permission to Just Be The hardest part isn't understanding this intellectually. It's giving yourself permission to act on it. We've been so thoroughly conditioned to measure our worth by our output that doing "nothing" feels irresponsible. Even when we know better. So here's your permission slip: Rest is not the absence of productivity. It's a different kind of productivity. The kind that makes everything else possible. You don't need to earn the right to be off. You're not a machine that only deserves maintenance when it's breaking down.  What Success Actually Looks Like Real productivity isn't cramming more into every hour. It's working hard when you work, and living fully when you don't. The goal isn't to become someone who never thinks about work in the evening. The goal is to become someone who can be present for the moments that matter, without work thoughts stealing those moments away. One Question for You If you didn't feel guilty about it, what would you do with your evening tonight? Not what you think you should do. What you actually want to do. That answer is worth listening to. The work will be there tomorrow. Tonight belongs to you.

Learn more
If-Then Planning: Your Secret Weapon Against Work Thought Intrusions

If-Then Planning: Your Secret Weapon Against Work Thought Intrusions

Work thoughts don't respect boundaries. They show up uninvited, usually at the worst times. Here's what doesn't work: promising yourself you'll stop thinking about work. Here's what does: having a plan for when it happens. Why Willpower is a Terrible Strategy We treat work-life balance like it's a willpower problem. Just decide to be present. Just choose not to think about work. Just be stronger. This fails because willpower is a limited resource. By the time you get home, you've already spent most of it making decisions, resisting distractions, and powering through tasks. Asking your depleted willpower to also police your thoughts is like asking someone who just ran a marathon to sprint home. Behavioral psychologists have studied this for decades. The research is clear: people who rely on willpower alone consistently fail. People who build systems consistently succeed. Enter Implementation Intentions In the 1990s, psychologist Peter Gollwitzer discovered something powerful. People who made specific if-then plans were significantly more likely to follow through on goals than people who just had good intentions. The format is simple: "If X happens, then I will do Y." Instead of vaguely trying to "be more present," you create specific trigger-response pairs. When work thoughts intrude (they will), you have a pre-loaded response ready to go. No willpower required. No decision fatigue. Just activation. Your brain loves this because it removes the mental load of figuring out what to do in the moment. The decision is already made. Build Your Personal If-Then Arsenal The most effective if-then plans are the ones you customize to your specific situation. Here's how to them: Step 1: Notice your patterns. What work stresses show up most often in your personal time? Be specific. "Work stress" is too vague. "Replaying the awkward exchange with my coworker" is specific. Step 2: Choose your response. What action helps you release that thought? It could be writing it down, taking deep breaths, reminding yourself of something, or doing a brief physical action. Step 3: Lock it in with if-then language. Write it out. The act of creating the plan strengthens the neural pathway. Template: If I [specific work thought or trigger], then I will [specific action to take]. Research shows that just creating the plan significantly increases the likelihood you'll follow through when the moment arrives. You're essentially pre-loading your response. Systems Beat Willpower Every Time If-then planning is one tool in a larger system for protecting your personal time. Some people combine it with shutdown rituals. Others use it alongside journaling practices that help process the day. Many find it most effective when paired with physical boundary markers (like changing clothes or closing a door). The point isn't perfection. Work thoughts will still show up. But when you have a system instead of just good intentions, you're no longer scrambling for a response every single time. You're prepared. Your Turn Think about the last work thought that intruded on your personal time. What was it specifically? Now create one if-then plan for the next time it shows up. Write it down somewhere you'll see it. Maybe on a sticky note by your laptop. Maybe in your phone. The act of writing it increases the odds you'll actually use it. The work will be there tomorrow. Tonight belongs to you.

Learn more
The 3-Breath Reset: A Mindfulness Trick That Works

The 3-Breath Reset: A Mindfulness Trick That Works

I used to think breathwork was something people did at expensive retreats while wearing linen pants and burning sage. Now that I’m older and dealing with real adult problems I kind of want to go to one of these.  I learned that you can get a little taste of these retreats wherever you are. Turns out, there's a biological off switch in your body that most people don't know how to use. It takes about 20 seconds and you can do it at your desk. The Vagus Nerve: Your Built-In Chill Button You have a nerve that runs from your brainstem down through your chest and into your abdomen. It's called the vagus nerve, and it's your body's direct line to your parasympathetic nervous system. That's the system responsible for calming you down. Think of your nervous system like a car. Your sympathetic nervous system is the gas pedal (stress, alertness, fight-or-flight). Your parasympathetic nervous system is the brake (rest, digest, recover). Most knowledge workers spend their entire workday with their foot on the gas. The vagus nerve is your brake pedal. And specific breathing patterns activate it. Dr. Andrew Huberman, a neuroscientist at Stanford, has done extensive research on this. When you take slow, deliberate breaths with longer exhales than inhales, you send a signal through the vagus nerve that tells your body "we're safe now, you can relax." This isn't meditation (even though I’m a big fan of that too). It's physiology. Why Three Breaths? You might be wondering why three. Why not five, or ten, or just one deep breath? Three is the sweet spot. It's enough time to trigger a measurable shift in your nervous system without requiring so much time that you'll skip it when you're busy. Research shows that even 60-90 seconds of intentional breathing can lower cortisol levels and heart rate. One breath feels rushed. Ten feels like a time commitment. Three is doable when you need it most. How to Do It Give it a try. It’s easy as pie: Breath 1: Inhale slowly through your nose for a count of 4. Exhale slowly through your mouth for a count of 6. Feel your shoulders drop slightly on the exhale. Breath 2: Same pattern. Inhale for 4, exhale for 6. Notice your jaw. Are you clenching? Let it soften. Breath 3: One more time. Inhale for 4, exhale for 6. On this last exhale, imagine releasing whatever tension you're holding. Total time: about 20 seconds. The longer exhale is key. That's what activates your vagus nerve most effectively. You're literally hacking your nervous system with the rhythm of your breath. When to Use It The 3-breath reset works best at transition points. Times when you're shifting from one mental state to another. Try it: Right after closing your laptop for the day Before walking into your house after work After a stressful meeting or phone call When you catch yourself spiraling about tomorrow's tasks First thing in the morning before opening your email These transition moments are when your nervous system needs a clear signal that you're changing gears. Without that signal, you carry the energy from one situation into the next. The Compound Effect Here's what nobody tells you about breathwork. The benefits compound. The first time you do three intentional breaths, you'll probably feel a little calmer. Maybe. The tenth time, you'll notice a more significant shift. By the fiftieth time, your body starts to recognize the pattern and responds faster. You're training your nervous system to know this is the signal for downshifting. Eventually, just starting the first breath triggers the relaxation response because your body knows what's coming. It's like muscle memory, but for your stress response. Your Turn Next time you finish work, before you do anything else, try it. Three breaths. Inhale for 4, exhale for 6. Pay attention to what changes. It might be subtle. That's fine. Subtle still counts and is usually the start of something bigger.

Learn more

Quick Links

© 2026 Equilibria. Powered by Shopify

  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa